J.J. McCarthy Dynasty Trade Value
QB · NYG · Age 23 · 2 yrs exp
Values refreshed October 12, 2026 · LeagueLogs Market Index
Connect your league for AI-powered trade suggestions built on your league's real rosters.
Got an offer involving J.J. McCarthy? Price the trade in the dynasty trade calculator → He's preloaded on one side — add the rest of the deal, picks included. Superflex league? Use the superflex calculator.
Value over time
Dynasty 1QB · Apr 28 – Oct 11How to trade J.J. McCarthy
- At 23, J.J. McCarthy fits both timelines — contenders can start him now and rebuilds can hold him, which keeps his market liquid and his price firm.
- Experts don't fully agree on him: of 4 FantasyPros experts, dynasty ranks run from #147 to #267 — an unusually wide split for his range of the board. Wide ranges cut both ways: more upside if the high rank is right, more risk if the low one is.
Where the experts land
Best-to-worst rank any contributing expert gave on each FantasyPros consensus board, with the consensus marked. These are expert board ranks — a different scale from the Market Index ranks above.
- Dynasty 1QBContestedconsensus #212·#147–#267·4 experts
- Dynasty Superflexconsensus #223·#93–#93·4 experts
Rookie-pick equivalents
Dynasty rookie picks valued closest to J.J. McCarthy on the Market Index. A useful frame for "would I trade X for this pick?" conversations.
- 2027 R2 (Mid)1,342
- 2026 3.051,345
- 2026 3.061,329
- 2026 3.071,322
- 2026 3.041,361
Players with similar dynasty value
QBs ranked closest to this player on the LeagueLogs Market Index — useful as a starting point for fair-value trade conversations.
J.J. McCarthy dynasty value FAQ
What is J.J. McCarthy worth in a dynasty trade?+
J.J. McCarthy's dynasty market value is 1,337 on the LeagueLogs Market Index (0–10,000 scale) — #212 overall and QB33 in 1QB dynasty leagues, and 1,842 (#126 overall) in superflex. In rookie-pick terms that's roughly a 2027 R2 (Mid). Values refresh throughout the week as expert consensus moves.
Is J.J. McCarthy worth more in superflex?+
Yes — like every startable quarterback, J.J. McCarthy is worth substantially more in superflex: 1,842 vs 1,337 in 1QB (38% higher). Always price QB trades on the superflex board if your league starts two.
Should you trade J.J. McCarthy right now?+
At 23, J.J. McCarthy fits both timelines — contenders can start him now and rebuilds can hold him, which keeps his market liquid and his price firm. His market price has been stable recently, so neither side is buying a spike or a dip. The fastest way to sanity-check a specific offer is to price both sides in the LeagueLogs dynasty trade calculator.
Full profile, injury status, and every format's value: J.J. McCarthy player page →
Expert consensus, ownership, injury, and news data via FantasyPros
Want to use these values for your roster? Try the free AI Trade Analyzer or the AI Trade Finder— both run on the same Market Index.
Take the rankings with you.
Push notifications when trades land, Scout in your pocket, and rankings movement built into your league feed.